Jack Selby speaking with attendees at the 2019 Arizona Technology Innovation Summit at The Duce in Phoenix, Arizona (Photo: Gage Skidmore)
Cover Jack Selby, seen here at the 2019 Arizona Technology Innovation Summit, is a member of the famous ‘PayPal mafia’ alongside Elon Musk, Reid Hoffman and his current boss Peter Thiel (Photo: Gage Skidmore)

The long-time managing director of billionaire entrepreneur Peter Thiel’s family office, Thiel Capital, is also behind Arizona’s largest venture fund, AZ-VC

About seven years ago, the identity of a mysterious diner who made news for leaving generous tips between $1,000 to $5,000 at restaurants was finally revealed. His name was Jack Selby, and he started his anonymous surprises in 2013—four years before he got found out. 

If Selby’s name sounds familiar for other reasons, it’s because he is a member of the famous “PayPal mafia”, a group of former founders and early employees of the fintech company who have gone on to start their own successful businesses. Said people include Tesla’s Elon Musk, LinkedIn’s Reid Hoffman, YouTube’s Steve Chen, and billionaire entrepreneur Peter Thiel, with whom Selby continues working closely today. 

Read more: Tech legends Steve Chen and Patrick Grove on regrets, survival and founder-market fit

In 2002, after PayPal was acquired by eBay, Selby and Thiel co-founded the macro hedge fund Clarium Capital Management. Selby now heads Thiel’s Los Angeles-based family office, Thiel Capital, from his home in Arizona, where he also runs AZ-VC, the venture capital firm he started in 2021.

His $110 million venture fund is currently Arizona’s largest, writing checks between $2 million to $5 million to growth-stage startups. 

Outside of investing, Selby has an equally colourful life as an independent producer with credits in films like Memory (2023) starring Jessica Chastain, His Three Daughters (2023) starring Elizabeth Olsen and Bernie (2011) starring Matthew McConaughey. As a student, he attended Hamilton College, a liberal arts school in New York. There, he met Thomas Tull, who would go on to start film production giant Legendary Entertainment. Tull would bring Selby onto several film and documentary projects. In 2014, Selby alongside Duncan Montgomery started the production company, High Frequency Entertainment.

During a private event at the Singapore office of Vertex Ventures Southeast Asia and India, Selby shared pearls of wisdom on his investment journey, approach and perception of the future. Here are some of the key takeaways.

Read more: Elon Musk’s Neuralink implants first computer chip into human brain

Tatler Asia
Selby (right) with American businessman, investor and TV personality Mark Cuban at the 2019 Arizona Technology Innovation Summit (Photo: Gage Skidmore)
Above Selby (right) with American businessman, investor and TV personality Mark Cuban at the 2019 Arizona Technology Innovation Summit (Photo: Gage Skidmore)

On how people’s career aspirations have changed

“When I graduated from college in 1996, all my friends wanted to work at Goldman Sachs, be a derivatives trader and [the like]. Today, years after the financial crisis, everybody wants to be an entrepreneur. And I think the societal value of everyone wanting [this] is great because it creates jobs and products.”

But the glamour of entrepreneurship is overblown

“It’s almost become like a game show. It’s like when I get on the escalator, I get off at the top and the confetti and balloons will drop, and I’m going to become a billionaire. I won the game. But that’s not how it works. Being an entrepreneur is not [like being on] an escalator. Some people don’t have the temperament to deal with near-death experiences.”

Although, if you’re in it, you might as well go big

“One of my favourite phrases, which I borrow from a buddy who’s a partner at Greylock [Partners], is you have to have equal parts grit and grandiosity. Grit is obvious. Grandiosity is that if you’re going to go through this crazy amount of work, working 24/7 for multiple years, you might as well be rewarded for it.”

Read more: How this Hong Kong entrepreneur is matchmaking impact startups with the right investors

On when the next PayPal will emerge

“It’s at the bottom of the cycle, when the cycle starts to turn. But it’s also really hard, so people just need to be eyes wide open about the reality.”

Being an entrepreneur is not [like being on] an escalator. Some people don’t have the temperament to deal with near-death experiences

- Jack Selby -

A big part of business success is luck

“In March 2000, PayPal closed its Series C, which was a $100 million round, right before the [dot-com] crash. We closed on Friday and the market crashed the following Monday. So we got very lucky. For so many things in life, it’s about timing and your fortune.”

On his relationship with Peter Thiel

“I met Peter when I was 24 and we both have a background in the currency business. I joked to my friends that when I met Peter, I met a really, really smart person and I vowed to hold on for dear life. Fast forward 25 years later, I’m still holding on with all my strength.”

Read more: Habits, humans and money: 6 books to inspire you to think differently

On solving actual needs

“Payments are really hard. If we hadn’t stumbled upon this unique marketplace like eBay, where both buyers and sellers equally want a payment solution, PayPal would probably not have come into existence.”

Tatler Asia
Jack Selby speaking with attendees at the 2022 Converge Tech Summit at The Waste Management Phoenix Open at the Skybar at TPC Scottsdale in Scottsdale, Arizona (Photo: Gage Skidmore)
Above Selby at the 2022 Converge Tech Summit in Scottsdale, Arizona (Photo: Gage Skidmore)

The jockey, not the horse

“For me as an investor, it’s all about the entrepreneur. When you invest in a company, the business might change seven, eight times. But if you invest in a bad person, however you define that, you have no chance. Focusing on the entrepreneur, making sure that person has the integrity, character, intelligence and the ability to think laterally is exceptionally important.”

Read more: Farhanna Farid on smashing records and becoming Singapore’s ‘Frankenstein of powerlifting’

The difference between investing and film

“Tech and finance, when you do it for a while, it can become routine. Whereas with film, you’re truly making art and it’s very difficult. If you’re fortunate enough to make a film that you throw up in the zeitgeist, the zeitgeist will either embrace it or say, ‘No thank you’. As an example, I don’t think The New York Times has ever written a positive review of any of the films we’ve made. But we’re still trying.”

If he wrote a book

“I would name the book, The dumbest guy in the room. And the subtitle will be, The trick is getting in the room. If you can put your ego aside and bump into really smart people, there’s nothing wrong with being second banana.”

Topics