Claudia Shaw: The Rise Of Malls Has Made Shopping Boring

People

July 5, 2017 | BY Chloe Street

The retail veteran shares how Hong Kong has changed since 1997

A veteran of the luxury retail industry, Claudia Shaw took a position with Chanel’s senior team in Asia in 1996 and has been with the company ever since. Her current position as ambassador and regional adviser involves overseeing buying for the entire Asia-Pacific region, hosting in-store events and styling for Chanel’s clients, including some of the biggest VIPs in Asia.

The Tatler 500 lister shares her thoughts on how Hong Kong retail has changed since 1997:

The shopper demographic has shifted over the past 20 years from Japanese to mainland Chinese tourists. The Japanese used to come because the prices were much more attractive. They shopped differently from the Chinese, though. In general, the Japanese are less gregarious, less ostentatious.

Meanwhile, the introduction of the Individual Visit Scheme in 2003 marked the beginning of a decade of huge growth in mainland Chinese visits to Hong Kong. Before that, a little over 7 million mainland Chinese visited Hong Kong each year. Ten years later that number had grown to 44 million. For the luxury stores, this meant mainland Chinese suddenly made up 70 per cent of your tourist clientele.

See also: Allan Zeman On How Hong Kong Nightlife Has Changed

The anti-corruption campaign hit every luxury brand in Hong Kong really hard. It was especially bad for watches and jewellery, but everybody has been hit. The effects of that campaign combined with pricing problems greatly reduced the numbers of mainland Chinese shoppers visiting Hong Kong. 

"I think the crackdown on corruption was a great thing. I always said it was not sustainable to have double-digit growth every year."

There was always going to be a point at which it would level off or maybe dip. It had to happen. It was just ridiculous, conspicuous spending. That said, while the numbers may have declined slightly, I believe we will always have mainland tourist shoppers. 

See also: Pacific Place Opens VIP Lounge

There’s been a massive expansion of stores for high-end brands. Twenty years ago at Chanel we had maybe four shops, and now we’ve got 10 or 11, including Macau. The rate of acceleration Hong Kong has seen on that front is unusual. In the past two years, some brands have been forced to close non-performing stores. I think the lesson is that any business that relies so heavily on tourists for income is at risk.

"The rise of malls has made shopping boring. We didn’t have so many in the past."

We didn’t have IFC, Pacific Place, nor Landmark as it is now. Before the handover, the larger stores were mostly Japanese department stores like Daimaru, Sogo, Matsuzakaya, Seibu. Then those businesses went from boom to bust in the early ’90s—in part, I think, due to the Asian financial crisis—and we began to transition to US-style malls. 

I love what they’ve done with Soho. I think it’s important that we don’t negate our heritage—which we tend to do—but I think we could do more to encourage local talent, whether it’s fashion or food or crafts, with affordable rents for studios and stores. 

There’s been a rise of activewear stores. They’re so much more a part of life these days as it’s become a trend for people to wear gym gear all day. It’s that horrible lifestyle trend we have adopted from America, hence these sportswear brands that have a lot of money—Adidas, Nike and so on—have expanded their footprint.

See also: Ronald Arculli On Hong Kong's Potential As A Culture City

people in this story

Claudia Shaw

Buyer and regional style adviser for Chanel; co-author (with Dominica Yang) of two cookbooks.
MORE PEOPLE IN THIS STORY